People have too much “stuff”. Manufacturers, retailers, wholesalers, and commercial enterprises all carry inventory of “stuff”, too. According to the Energy Information Administration’s (EIA’s) own statistics, in 2018, the US had over 17.4 billion ft2 of warehouse and storage. Growing from just 13 billion ft2 in 2012, warehouse and storage space is the fastest growing and now the largest use of commercial space in the US, overtaking office space for the first time in modern history.
Almost every one of those buildings contains storage racks. And this doesn’t include the mercantile spaces. You can go to a big box retailer and buy cereal from a lower shelf while pallets of grain or packaged drinks sit 20-30 feet above, waiting to be introduced to the customer.
There is no specific OSHA regulation for anchoring storage racks – which are available in myriad variations. Improper (or missing!) anchorage of even single-level storage racks represents a huge problem for property damage or injury. Side loads from passersby, loaders or material removal can tip over racks. Steel beams falling even a few feet can do enough damage to crush inventory, break bones, or even kill.
A standard pallet storage rack column. Notice the unused anchor hole on the bottom plate. Oftentimes only one anchor hole must be bolted down. Left completely unattached to the floor, however, storage racks are not installed according to ANSI MH16.1. They can lift, slip or tip over, creating possible damage to inventory or harm to bystanders.
This is why ANSI MH16.1 section 1.4.7 prescribes minimum anchorage at every column. For example, the 2012 version states:
The bottom of all columns shall be furnished with column base plates, as specified in section 7.1. All rack columns shall be anchored to the floor with anchor bolts, which shall be designed in accordance with Section 7.3, to resist all applicable forces as described in section 2.1 or Section 2.2.
Each column in a storage rack must be anchored to the ground according to the ANSI standard. But many installations do not use anchors, and the IBC does not explicitly require anchors on every storage rack (the IBC focuses on seismic loading).
Local building codes vary as to rack installation inspections. In South Carolina, for example, any rack over 6 ft. tall requires permitting in many jurisdictions. Once the racks have been installed, they are part of the structure. Fire codes also govern the materials stored on racks.
Center of Gravity
Sometimes, there is a need to determine how eccentric a storage rack’s weight has become. I’ve seen cantilevered storage of steel beams where the main column failed by bending due to eccentric loading (I.E., once cantilevered side had too much weight, causing the main support beam to bend). The center of gravity for stored material can be tedious to calculate by hand, but its concept is relatively simple. The one-dimensional center of gravity formula is as follows:
CG=Σ(ℎ×)/Σℎ
Engineers and CAD professionals can easily calculate weight based on worst case scenarios for any given storage rack and set of conditions. Doing so can help the user decide how to label their racks for maximum capacity (which is also recommended in ANSI MH16.1).
Among the safety features suggested for high-traffic areas, high-visibility base protection shields can prevent accidental damage to columns and offer barriers that can be repaired without calling in storage rack professionals. Image courtesy of Pixabay.
Whose Responsibility is Safe Installation?
Leased buildings sometimes come with racks installed by the building owner. Other times, the manufacturer may intend to load light materials onto racks, or inspections get missed during a rearrangement of a warehouse space in a manufacturing facility. But at the end of the day, the business loading the racks must understand the racks’ limitations.
Storage racks are static, easily ignored parts of our manufacturing environment. When properly installed and maintained, they perform their duty across every industry. Falls, damaged inventory, and lost work all present hazards if left unchecked. Skilled forensic engineers with analytical experience and knowledge of ANSI MH16.1 are ideally suited for identifying whether storage rack failures originated with the manufacturer, installer or somewhere else. Give us a call at The Warren Group if you would like to discuss storage rack-related issues.
Brian Tenace is a Licensed Professional Engineer and holds a FenestrationMaster® Professional Certification. He has over 15 years of manufacturing and machine design experience in production and quality-driven environments. Brian earned a Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering from the University of Florida. Over his engineering career, Brian worked in fenestration design in addition to designing hardware, above/below ground spill containment vessels, extrusions, dies and molds. He conducted root cause analyses for fatigue, weld, and corrosion failures in steel, springs, pressure vents and sheet metals. He developed tests according to standards and custom specifications as needed, along with modifying manufacturing processes. His failure analysis experience includes impact testing, design for ballistic protection, water infiltration resistance and corrosion. Brian has an in-depth knowledge of many standards with emphasis on fenestration standards and impact standards. Brian regularly investigates property damage claims involving machinery and equipment in a variety of environments, as well as personal injury, wrongful death, and product liability claims for both insurance adjusters and attorneys.
As we all know, change is a part of life. Sometimes the results from change are good. And we know sometimes change may result in things becoming worse, although it may not be immediately evident. I think it is safe to say that when we intentionally make changes to something, our goal is to make it better with respect to one or more metrics. Engineers working in manufacturing facilities are often asked to make changes to existing machines and processes for multiple reasons: Read More
So, you find yourself with a machine hazard that you need to guard. Where do your turn for guidance regarding guards? Several resources are available for the person who is tasked with providing machine guarding.
The United States government provides resources in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). These can be found at www.ecfr.gov. Title 29 of the CFR, section 1910 covers “General Industry” regulations. 1910 Subpart O, covers Machinery and Machine Guarding. Definitions are covered in 1910.211 and it is wise to understand how terms are defined. For instance, in 1910.211(a)(1), Point of operations is defined by the regulation as “that point at which cutting, shaping, boring, or forming is accomplished on the stock.” Read More
Waterjet cutting machines (often simply called ‘waterjets’ in the industry) are essentially platforms that use ultra-high pressure water to manufacture cut parts with accuracy as high as .001 inch. They can cut materials ranging from glass and stone to steel and even plastics. Such machines can cost under $1.00 per minute to run, even including labor. Waterjets are some of the most versatile cutting tools available today. They produce virtually no heat-affected zone. They also use CNC (computer numerically controlled) programs, which allow continuously variable speeds for different edge conditions and cut quality. The waterjet dissipates heat, and the jet stream minimizes harmful chemical vaporization from cut materials. Small and mid-sized companies throughout the U.S. depend on these powerful tools to manage all sorts of custom two-dimensional cuts.
But waterjets present unique hazards to the manufacturing environment. The following challenges require special attention: Read More
In 2023, the new European Machinery Regulation was published which replaces the 2006 Machinery Directive. The 2023 Machinery Regulation is slated to be entered into force and application on January 20, 2027. A number of changes and/or clarifications are included in this new Machinery Regulation, not the least of which is the definition for “substantial modification.” Read More
That is always good advice to follow if you are a forklift driver! Operating a forklift can be a dangerous occupation. There are approximately 1 million forklifts (powered industrial trucks) in the US workplace today, and it is estimated that just over 10% of those are involved in some type of accident every year. Forklift accidents result in dozens of deaths and thousands of non-fatal injuries annually. About one out of every four of those accidents involves a tipping or overturning forklift, making this the most common type of industrial truck accident. Read More
Falls were the number one cause of preventable non-fatal injuries and the number two cause of preventable deaths in the US in 2019 (CDC and NEISS data). Slip and falls occur when there is an unexpected loss of traction between a person’s foot and the walking surface. Slip and falls are common and can occur in any setting where people walk, including homes, workplaces, and public areas. Slip and falls can result in serious injuries, particularly for older adults.
The human gait cycle consists of four phases: Read More
Machine guards can be compared to the clothes we wear every day. Indeed, they serve a very important purpose. Imagine someone leaving their home on a fine, sunny morning wearing nothing but a smile. Wonder how far they will get through the day before things start going poorly for this individual?
There will be more than a few raised eyebrows and blushes when he stops into the local Starbucks for his usual morning double-dipped and whipped, chocolaty chip with a touch of pumpkin spice cappuccino fix. Good luck with that! Probably going to leave disappointed, empty-handed, and likely wearing handcuffs. This will be the beginning of a very long, very bad day for that individual. Had he recognized the risks associated with this type of behavior, and then put forth a little effort to cover up, he would have prevented many unfavorable and possibly life-changing personal and legal problems from ever occurring!
And so it is with properly guarding a machine. Machine safeguarding helps to protect workers from preventable injuries. Read More
Ladders…not a particularly exciting topic I’ll admit. But hey, we need ladders to help us accomplish all kinds of tasks. Most people have used at least one of the many types of ladders that are available today. And the odds are probably pretty good that many of those users strayed outside the limits of safety a time or two while on a ladder. It is amazing the risks some people will take to save some time or avoid the inconvenience of getting down to move the ladder into a safer position. I wonder how many of those risks would be taken on a ladder if the users knew they were on camera.
Think about astronaut Neil Armstrong. He travelled by rocket almost 239,000 miles through space and Read More
Hazard, risk, and harm are terms that are used in the world of machine safeguarding. How do these words shape the concept of machine safeguarding? Let’s look a little deeper….
Hazard, which Merriam-Webster defines as a noun, lists its first meaning as a source of danger.
1: a source of danger
2a: the effect of unpredictable and unanalyzable forces in determining events : CHANCE, RISK
